This book is where the film really began to diverge from the original story, consolidating the plot into a simpler narrative that fits a bit better for a 90 minute comedy. It does make this a weird book to look back on, as for every great scene that made it in there are two or three that didn't.
Adaptation is a difficult process, and I would be the first to admit that I love the faithfulness of Edgar Wright's movie, but there's a lot cut there that detracts from the overall story, especially Scott's journey towards being less of an ass.
So this is, in essence, an extended cut of the film, even if it was here first. Wright captured the tone admirably which means that the changes he made fit with the characters and situations in the book even if they don't exactly correspond. Basically, Scott Pilgrim vs the World is the anti-Watchmen; thematically consistent, if sometimes removed from the original plot.
Anyway, in conclusion, the book is good, and the film of Watchmen is not.
Bryan Lee O'Malley, Scott Pilgrim vs The World
Brian K Vaughan, Runaways
Kieron Gillen, Young Avengers
Matt Fraction, Hawkeye
Brian K Vaughan, Runaways
Kieron Gillen, Young Avengers
Matt Fraction, Hawkeye
No comments:
Post a Comment